Single Member LLC – No Protection For Member?

The single member limited liability company is a business entity shrouded in a cloud of mystery when it comes to liability protection for the sole member. Simply put, there is conflicting information on the web as to whether the single member LLC provides protection or no protection to the owner.

Shield of ProtectionProtection In General

Why do you form a business entity? For most people, the reason is to create a shield of protection between the liabilities and debts of the LLC and their personal assets. For others, however, the purpose is to use the entity as part of an asset protection or estate plan. A single member LLC provides protection in the first instance in most cases, but rarely the second case. We will focus on the first instance for the purpose of this article.

Business Debts and Liabilities

You decide to launch a website selling lampshades for people to wear at parties. Since booze will inevitably be involved, you make the wise choice to set up a limited liability company. As the only owner, the entity is designated a single member limited liability company automatically. An owner is known as a “member” in a limited liability company.

So, does this business entity provide you with protection from lawsuits and business debts? Yes…and no.

Definite Protection

An LLC will protect you from liability claims arising from the business itself so long as the entity is setup, capitalized and run correctly. For example, let’s assume we move forward with the lampshade website. The business does well, but an idiot attempts to drive his car while wearing one of our lampshades. He crashes and sues the business. In this scenario, he can only sue the LLC. You, the single member, are protected. However, this is not the end of the story.

No Protection

In certain situations, the single member LLC will provide you with no protection. No protection is provided where you are personally involved in the disputed action and sued as an individual based on the involvement. As always, an example can show how this might play out.

Let’s assume you run into a problem with your inventory. The Chinese company making your lampshades is behind schedule by 45 days. Facing dwindling inventory, you decide to drive two hours to a wholesaler selling similar lampshades. You fall asleep at the wheel and cause a bad accident in which numerous people are badly injured.

lampshade partyTechnically, you are on a business trip and can argue only the company should be sued in the matter since you were acting as an employee on the drive. This argument will fail. The injured parties will be able to sue the LLC AND you personally because you were personally involved [driving]. This is often referred to as “top down” liability by attorneys because the suing party “jumps” the protection shield by going after the single member directly. Let’s take a look at another example just to be sure you have the concept down.

I have good news. The lampshade website is a huge hit. You decide to open retail stores in malls. Customers, however, can be annoying. One day, an employee gets fed up and takes a swing at a customer. Three days later, you do the same thing.

In this example, the customer who was punched by the employee can only sue the LLC. The liability shield for the LLC will protect you, the single owner, from being sued personally. The potential debt is purely the responsibility of the LLC.

Now we turn to your punch. In this situation, the customer can sue you directly because you threw the punch. Your personal action gives rise to potential liability and the LLC will provide no protection.

Got it?

Lesson

The lesson from all this is to make sure you set up and run the limited liability company in the correct manner. If you are paying $99 to get it set up, you are asking for trouble with issues such as capitalization.

Assuming you do set the entity up correctly, it is vital all business be done under the name of the company. Contracts should be signed in the name of the company. Personal guarantees should be avoided. Domains should be owned by the company, not you, and so on.

If you need assistance with a California limited liability company, feel free to contact me for a consultation.

Richard A. Chapo, Esq.
@richardachapo